Amberen vs Bonafide: Which Menopause Supplement Is Better for Hot Flashes?

Amberen vs Bonafide: capsules and pollen extract tablets side by side on a kitchen table

Written by

in

Amberen and Bonafide’s Relizen both target hot flashes without hormone replacement therapy, but they work in very different ways: Amberen is a blend of succinates, minerals and amino acids, while Relizen is a purified Swedish flower pollen extract. Both have placebo-controlled trials behind them, so the better pick usually comes down to your symptoms, your budget and your health history.

Disclosure: My husband, Brandon, does freelance marketing work for Immunotec, the company that makes She+. I got She+ free as an early tester.

Key takeaways
  • Amberen is a succinate, mineral and amino acid blend. In a pooled analysis of two 90-day trials (227 women aged 42 to 60), it eased 16 of 21 menopause symptoms and lowered anxiety compared with placebo.
  • Bonafide Relizen is a Swedish flower pollen extract. In a placebo-controlled trial, 65% of women taking it had fewer hot flashes, compared with 38% on placebo.
  • Pick Amberen if you want a lower-cost option for a mix of symptoms like mood and weight. Pick Relizen if hot flashes and night sweats are your main complaint.
  • Both take time. Amberen’s trials ran 90 days, and Bonafide recommends at least three months of Relizen.
  • Talk to your doctor first, especially with a history of breast cancer, if you take an antidepressant, or if you have any unexpected bleeding.

Why I looked into Amberen vs Bonafide

About a year ago my perimenopause showed up all at once: low energy, sleep that kept getting worse, hot flashes during the day, and waking up hot and sweaty at night. I tried magnesium first because so many women recommend it, and it didn’t help me. So I started reading labels in the supplement aisle, and the two names I kept seeing were Amberen and Bonafide.

I ended up going a different direction (I’ll tell you what I use at the end), but a lot of you have asked me how these two compare. So I dug into the actual studies, the labels and what other women say. If you’re still figuring out what you’re dealing with, my complete list of perimenopause symptoms is a good place to start.

Amberen vs Bonafide at a glance

One quick note: Bonafide is a company, not a single product. Its hot flash product is Relizen, so that’s what I’m comparing here. Bonafide also sells Thermella for hot flashes, Revaree for vaginal dryness and Noctera for sleep, according to its website.

Main ingredientDaily doseKey studyApprox. price
She+ by Immunotec (what I use)Black cohosh and red clover, plus ginger and glucomannan1 jelly stickIngredient research: black cohosh and red clover trialsAbout $44 a box on subscription ($59 retail)
AmberenSuccinate blend with minerals, amino acids and vitamin E2 capsules after breakfastPooled 90-day RCTs, 227 womenAbout $26 to $30 a bottle
Bonafide RelizenPurified Swedish flower pollen extract2 tablets3-month RCT: 65% vs 38% had fewer hot flashes$42 a month on subscription ($58 single box)

How Amberen works and what the research shows

Amberen’s formula is built around succinates, which are compounds your cells use when they make energy. Its proprietary blend lists ammonium succinate, calcium disuccinate, monosodium L-glutamate, glycine, magnesium disuccinate and zinc difumarate, plus vitamin E, in a 400 mg two-capsule serving, according to a Cooper Clinic review of the label. The retail label directs one capsule of each color daily after breakfast, and a 60-count bottle was $29.97 at Walmart when I checked.

The best study is a 2019 pooled analysis in Obstetrics and Gynecology International that combined two identical randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials. It included 227 women aged 42 to 60 with mild to moderate menopause symptoms, and they took Amberen or placebo for 90 days. The Amberen group improved on 16 of 21 symptoms on the Greene Climacteric Scale and had a significant drop in anxiety compared with placebo. They also saw reductions in weight, BMI and waist and hip measurements.

One detail worth knowing: the same study found that blood estradiol levels rose significantly from baseline in the Amberen group. That’s part of why I’d loop in your doctor before trying it if you have a history of hormone-sensitive cancer.

Amberen

Best for a mix of symptoms

A good fit if your perimenopause is more than hot flashes: irritability, anxiety, low energy and that stubborn weight around the middle. It’s also the lower-cost option of the two.

How Bonafide Relizen works and what the research shows

Relizen is made from a purified extract of Swedish flower pollen (sold in Europe as Femal and Sérélys). GoodRx explains that the mechanism isn’t fully mapped out, but studies suggest it works on serotonin, a bit like the way SSRIs are used for hot flashes, and that the allergens are removed during processing (GoodRx). Memorial Sloan Kettering notes that lab research found no estrogenic activity in the extract (MSK).

The main trial is a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study in Climacteric (2005) of 64 menopausal women. After three months of two tablets each morning, 65% of women taking the pollen extract had fewer hot flashes, compared with 38% on placebo. Hot flashes logged in their daily diaries dropped 27% compared with the placebo group, and quality-of-life scores improved too.

Researchers have also studied the extract in breast cancer survivors. In a 2024 Italian placebo-controlled trial of 39 women, the pollen extract group had fewer hot flashes after three months, along with less sweating, irritability and fatigue, and it was well tolerated. A 2024 review in Menopause pooling five studies (420 women) found improvements in hot flashes, night disturbances and mood scores after three months of use.

Bonafide sells Relizen for $42 a month on subscription or $58 for a single box, and recommends taking it daily for at least three months (Bonafide).

Bonafide Relizen

Best for hot flashes and night sweats

A good fit if hot flashes and night sweats are the main thing keeping you up, and you’re willing to give it a full three months to show what it can do.

What women say about each

On the EmpowHer community, women who tried Amberen describe a wide range of experiences. Several said their hot flashes and night sweats dropped a lot, one going from dozens a day to roughly one every couple of days, and others mentioned better sleep and more energy. A few noticed changes within days, while others said it took about a month. One woman reported spotting after about six weeks, and her blood work showed her estradiol had gone up (EmpowHer).

Pollen extract comes up often among women who can’t take hormones. On the Breast Cancer Now forum, one member shared that women she’d read about on hormone-blocking treatment found their hot flushes and night sweats much better on it, and another said her breast care nurse wanted to see the details before she started, which is exactly the right instinct.

The common thread in both camps is patience: give whichever one you pick a couple of months before you decide.

How to choose between Amberen and Bonafide

If this sounds like youConsider
Hot flashes and night sweats are the main problemRelizen
Mood, anxiety and weight changes are bothering you as much as the heatAmberen
You want the lowest monthly costAmberen
You take an SSRI or other antidepressantAsk your doctor before either, especially Relizen
You want a non-pill format, or a black cohosh and red clover combinationShe+ by Immunotec

Whatever you choose, give it a fair trial. Hot flashes can last a long time; in the large SWAN study, the median duration of frequent hot flashes was 7.4 years (JAMA Internal Medicine, 2015). Keeping a simple diary of how many flashes you have each day makes it much easier to tell if something is working. For more ideas you can stack with a supplement, see my guide to reducing hot flashes naturally.

Talk to your doctor first

  • Breast or uterine cancer history: The Amberen study found estradiol levels rose in users, and pollen extract studies in cancer survivors are still small. Get your oncologist’s OK first.
  • Antidepressants: Because Relizen may act on serotonin, GoodRx advises checking with a pharmacist or prescriber before combining it with SSRIs or other serotonin-affecting drugs.
  • Unexpected bleeding: Spotting or a period after months without one should always be checked out.
  • Blood thinners, liver problems, pregnancy: Run any supplement past your doctor, including black cohosh, ginger and red clover products.
  • MSG sensitivity: Amberen’s blend includes monosodium L-glutamate.

Why I went with She+ instead

Neither Amberen nor Relizen combines black cohosh and red clover, the two plant ingredients with the most hot flash research behind them, and that’s a big reason I said yes when I was offered She+ as an early tester. A 2023 meta-analysis in Menopause of 22 studies and 2,310 women found black cohosh improved hot flashes and overall menopause symptoms compared with placebo, and a 2021 review in Nutrients found red clover cut about 1.73 hot flashes a day compared with placebo. I wrote more about that pairing in my black cohosh guide.

I’ve been taking She+ for about two months. My sleep is the biggest change: my Oura ring used to show me waking up about every 10 minutes, and now my sleep scores are in the 80s and 90s. I have more energy, my hot flashes have come down, and I actually look forward to the apple blueberry taste. It’s a jelly stick, so there’s nothing to swallow. It isn’t hormone replacement therapy (HRT), and like any supplement, it’s worth clearing with your doctor. I go into all the details in my full She+ review.

“I’m sleeping better, I have more energy, and my hot flashes have come down.”Denise Walsh, She+ tester. Individual results vary.

FAQ

Which is better, Amberen or Bonafide?

It depends on your symptoms. Bonafide’s Relizen has a placebo-controlled trial focused on hot flashes (65% of women had fewer flashes vs 38% on placebo). Amberen’s trials looked at a broad mix of symptoms, including anxiety and weight. If heat is your main problem, Relizen is the more targeted choice; if you have a mix of symptoms on a budget, Amberen may suit you better.

How long does it take Amberen or Relizen to work?

Plan on two to three months. Amberen’s trials ran 90 days, and Bonafide says Relizen’s hot flash benefits show up by month two to three and recommends at least three months of daily use.

Can I take Amberen and Relizen together?

There’s no research on combining them, so ask your doctor or pharmacist. It’s usually easier to try one at a time so you can tell what’s helping.

Is Relizen safe after breast cancer?

Lab studies show the pollen extract has no estrogenic activity, and a small 2024 trial in breast cancer survivors found it well tolerated. Still, talk to your oncologist before starting anything new.

Is She+ like Amberen or Bonafide?

All three are supplements, not hormone replacement therapy. She+ by Immunotec is a once-a-day jelly stick with black cohosh and red clover, which neither Amberen nor Relizen contains. You can read my honest She+ review for my two-month results.

Sources

  1. Succinate-based dietary supplement for menopausal symptoms: a pooled analysis of two identical randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trials. Obstet Gynecol Int. 2019. PMC6875258
  2. Winther K, Rein E, Hedman C. Femal, a herbal remedy made from pollen extracts, reduces hot flushes and improves quality of life in menopausal women. Climacteric. 2005. PubMed 16096172
  3. Purified cytoplasmic pollen extract for hot flashes in breast cancer survivors: randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Gynecol Endocrinol. 2024. PubMed 38760920
  4. The efficacy of purified pollen extract for reducing vasomotor symptoms in women: systematic review and meta-analysis. Menopause. 2024. PubMed 38194609
  5. Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. Pollen extract. mskcc.org
  6. GoodRx. Relizen for menopause. goodrx.com
  7. Bonafide. Relizen product page. hellobonafide.com
  8. Cooper Clinic. Is Amberen a good choice for menopause relief? cooperaerobics.com
  9. Avis NE, et al. Duration of menopausal vasomotor symptoms over the menopause transition (SWAN). JAMA Intern Med. 2015. PubMed 25686030
  10. Black cohosh for menopausal symptoms: meta-analysis. Menopause. 2023. PubMed 37192826
  11. Red clover for menopausal hot flushes: systematic review and meta-analysis. Nutrients. 2021. PubMed 33920485

This article reflects one person’s experience and is for general information only. It is not medical advice. Talk with your healthcare provider before starting any supplement.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *