Estroven Complete and Remifemin are two of the most popular non-HRT menopause supplements in the drugstore aisle, and they work in different ways: Estroven Complete uses a rhapontic rhubarb root extract (ERr 731), while Remifemin uses a German black cohosh extract. Both have placebo-controlled trials behind them, so the better pick mostly comes down to your symptoms, your budget and your health history.
Disclosure: My husband, Brandon, does freelance marketing work for Immunotec, the company that makes She+. I got She+ free as an early tester.
- Estroven Complete is one 4 mg caplet a day of rhapontic rhubarb root extract (ERr 731). In a 12-week placebo-controlled trial of 112 perimenopausal women, menopause symptom scores fell by more than half, along with fewer hot flashes.
- Remifemin is a black cohosh extract taken twice a day. In a 12-week trial of 304 women, it beat placebo on menopause symptoms, with the hot flash score showing the clearest change and the biggest benefit early in the transition.
- Pick Estroven if you want one caplet a day and a wide spread of symptoms covered. Pick Remifemin if hot flashes are your main complaint and you like the idea of black cohosh, the most studied herb for menopause.
- Both take a few weeks. Women commonly report changes anywhere from a couple of weeks to about two months in.
- Talk to your doctor first if you’re pregnant, have liver problems, take blood thinners or have a history of breast or uterine cancer.
Why I compared Estroven and Remifemin
About a year ago my perimenopause showed up in a pile: low energy, sleep that kept getting worse, hot flashes during the day and waking up hot and sweaty at night. I tried magnesium first because so many women swear by it, and it didn’t help me. After that I spent a lot of time reading supplement labels, and Estroven and Remifemin were the two names I saw on nearly every shelf.
These days I take She+ by Immunotec (more on that at the end, and in my She+ review), but readers keep asking how these two stack up. So I went through the studies, the labels and what other women say. If you’re still sorting out what you’re dealing with, my complete list of perimenopause symptoms is a good place to start.
Estroven vs Remifemin at a glance
Estroven sells several formulas. I’m comparing Estroven Complete, the multi-symptom version built on rhapontic rhubarb, since it’s the one with the most research behind its main ingredient.
| Main ingredient | Daily dose | Key study | Approx. price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| She+ by Immunotec (what I use) | Black cohosh and red clover, plus ginger and glucomannan | 1 jelly stick | Ingredient research: black cohosh and red clover trials | About $44 a box on subscription ($59 retail) |
| Estroven Complete | Rhapontic rhubarb root extract (ERr 731), 4 mg | 1 caplet | 12-week RCT, 112 perimenopausal women | About $20 for 28 caplets |
| Remifemin | Isopropanolic black cohosh extract | 2 tablets (morning and evening) | 12-week RCT, 304 women | About $25 for 60 tablets |
How Estroven Complete works and what the research shows
Each Estroven Complete caplet has 4 mg of rhapontic rhubarb root extract, providing 2.2 mg of rhaponticin and 1 mg of desoxyrhaponticin. You take one caplet a day, at any time, with or without food. The 28-count pack was $19.97 at Vitacost when I checked.
This extract, called ERr 731, has been prescribed by gynecologists in Germany for decades. In a multicenter, placebo-controlled trial in Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine (2009), 112 perimenopausal women took one ERr 731 tablet or a placebo daily for 12 weeks. Menopause Rating Scale scores in the ERr 731 group dropped from 27.0 to 12.4 points, compared with 27.0 to 24.0 on placebo. Hot flashes, their weighted severity score and every individual symptom on the scale improved too.
A 2024 meta-analysis in the Journal of Biomedical Research pooled four high-quality studies with 390 women and found ERr 731 significantly lowered Menopause Rating Scale scores compared with control. And a 2026 report in Frontiers in Pharmacology followed women for a full 52 weeks and found symptom relief held up over the year, with more than 90% describing themselves as in good or very good spirits by the end.
One more reassuring study: a 2025 German cohort in Breast Cancer Research and Treatment compared 5,686 women prescribed ERr 731 with 17,058 matched women and found no increase in breast cancer diagnoses.
Estroven Complete
Best for one-a-day convenienceA good fit if you want a single small caplet and your perimenopause is a mix of hot flashes, sleep, mood and irritability. It’s also the easiest on the budget per day.
How Remifemin works and what the research shows
Remifemin is a black cohosh extract made in Germany. The label directs one tablet in the morning and one in the evening with water, notes that consistent use gives the best results, and says not to combine it with other black cohosh products. A 60-count bottle (a month’s supply) was listed at $24.99 at Walmart.
The key study is a randomized, double-blind trial in Obstetrics and Gynecology (2005) of 304 women at 24 gynecology practices. Over 12 weeks, the isopropanolic black cohosh extract was more effective than placebo on the Menopause Rating Scale, and the authors noted the size of the effect was similar to results from hormone therapy studies using the same scale. The hot flash subscore showed the clearest benefit, women early in the transition improved the most, and side effects and lab results were similar to placebo.
That early-transition finding is good news for those of us in perimenopause. It also lines up with the bigger picture on black cohosh: a 2023 meta-analysis in Menopause of 22 studies and 2,310 women found black cohosh improved hot flashes and overall menopause symptoms compared with placebo. I cover the herb in more depth in my black cohosh guide.
Remifemin
Best for hot flashesA good fit if hot flashes and night sweats are the main event and you’d like the herb with the longest research track record. Plan on giving it at least a couple of months.
What women say about each
Estroven Complete has a 4.4 out of 5 average from nearly 950 ratings at Sam’s Club. Reviewers who mention hot flashes mostly describe fewer of them or milder night sweats, several say they sleep better with fewer sweaty wake-ups, and timelines range from about a week to a few weeks. A couple mention mild stomach upset at first. On Mumsnet, one woman in a thread about menopause supplements said Estroven helped her.
Remifemin earned 3.9 out of 5 from 100 reviews on ProductReview.com.au, with 78% positive. A common theme is sleeping through the night again with fewer sweats, and some women also mention better mood and more energy. Timelines range from a few days to about five weeks, and a lot of reviewers tell others to stick with it. On the Breast Cancer Network Australia forum, one member said it took about eight weeks to kick in and then gave her months of good relief, and another started it at her oncologist’s suggestion, which is a great example of checking with your care team first.
How to choose between Estroven and Remifemin
| If this sounds like you | Consider |
|---|---|
| You want one caplet a day and nothing to remember at night | Estroven Complete |
| Hot flashes and night sweats are your biggest problem | Remifemin |
| Mood, irritability and sleep bother you as much as the heat | Estroven Complete |
| You have liver problems or a history of liver disease | Ask your doctor; skip black cohosh products unless cleared |
| You’d like black cohosh and red clover together, in a jelly instead of a pill | She+ by Immunotec |
Whichever you choose, give it a fair run. Hot flashes can stick around a while; in the large SWAN study the median duration of frequent hot flashes was 7.4 years (JAMA Internal Medicine, 2015). A simple daily tally of flashes makes it much easier to tell whether something is working. For habits you can stack with any supplement, see my guide to reducing hot flashes naturally, and if your nights are the hardest part, how to stop night sweats.
Talk to your doctor first
- Pregnancy or breastfeeding: Estroven’s label says not to take it if you’re pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive, and black cohosh should be avoided in pregnancy too.
- Liver problems: The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements has noted about 83 reports of liver problems in people taking black cohosh, without proven cause. If you have liver disease, ask first, and stop and call your doctor if you notice dark urine, yellowing skin or stomach pain.
- Breast or uterine cancer history: Get your oncologist’s OK before any menopause supplement, including these two.
- Blood thinners and other medications: Run any herbal product past your pharmacist, especially if you take warfarin or several prescriptions.
- Unexpected bleeding: Spotting or a period after months without one should always be checked out.
Why I went with She+ instead
Estroven Complete is a rhubarb extract and Remifemin is black cohosh, but neither pairs black cohosh with red clover, the two plant ingredients with the most hot flash research behind them. That combination is a big part of why I said yes when I was offered She+ as an early tester. Alongside the black cohosh research above, a 2021 review in Nutrients found red clover cut about 1.73 hot flashes a day compared with placebo.
I’ve been taking She+ for about two months. Sleep is the biggest change for me: my Oura ring used to show me waking up about every 10 minutes, and now my sleep scores land in the 80s and 90s. I have more energy, my hot flashes have come down, and I look forward to the apple blueberry taste. It’s a jelly stick, so there’s nothing to swallow. It isn’t hormone replacement therapy (HRT), and like any supplement it’s worth clearing with your doctor. I share everything in my full She+ by Immunotec review.
“I’m sleeping better, I have more energy, and my hot flashes have come down.”Denise Walsh, She+ tester. Individual results vary.
FAQ
Which is better, Estroven or Remifemin?
It depends on what’s bothering you most. Remifemin’s black cohosh extract showed its clearest benefit on hot flashes in a 304-woman trial, while Estroven Complete’s rhubarb extract improved a broad range of symptoms in a 112-woman perimenopause trial. If you want one caplet a day, Estroven is simpler; if hot flashes are the main issue, Remifemin is a good place to start.
Does Estroven Complete contain black cohosh?
No. Estroven Complete’s active ingredient is rhapontic rhubarb root extract (ERr 731). Some other Estroven formulas have used different ingredients, so check the label of the specific product you buy.
Can I take Estroven and Remifemin together?
There’s no research on combining them, so it’s best to pick one, give it a fair trial and ask your doctor or pharmacist before stacking supplements. Remifemin’s label also says not to take it with other black cohosh products.
How long does it take for Estroven or Remifemin to work?
The main trials for both ran 12 weeks. Women commonly report noticing changes anywhere from a week or two to about two months, and Remifemin’s label says consistent use gives the best results.
Are Estroven and Remifemin hormone replacement therapy?
No. Both are plant-based dietary supplements, not HRT. If you’re considering hormone therapy, that’s a conversation to have with your doctor.
Sources
- Kaszkin-Bettag M, et al. Confirmation of the efficacy of ERr 731 in perimenopausal women with menopausal symptoms. Altern Ther Health Med. 2009. Europe PMC
- Efficacy evaluation of standardized Rheum rhaponticum root extract (ERr 731) on symptoms of menopause: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Biomed Res. 2024. Europe PMC
- The special extract ERr 731 from the root of rhapontic rhubarb: efficacy in headache/migraine and further climacteric complaints in women in the perimenopause. Front Pharmacol. 2026. Europe PMC
- Association between Extract Rheum rhaponticum 731 (ERr 731) prescription and subsequent breast cancer. Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2025. Europe PMC
- Osmers R, et al. Efficacy and safety of isopropanolic black cohosh extract for climacteric symptoms. Obstet Gynecol. 2005. Europe PMC
- Black cohosh for menopausal symptoms: 2023 meta-analysis. Menopause. 2023. PubMed
- Red clover for menopausal hot flushes: 2021 systematic review and meta-analysis. Nutrients. 2021. PubMed
- Avis NE, et al. Duration of menopausal vasomotor symptoms over the menopause transition (SWAN). JAMA Intern Med. 2015. PubMed
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Black Cohosh: Health Professional Fact Sheet. ods.od.nih.gov
- Estroven Complete Multi-Symptom Menopause Relief, product label. Vitacost
- Remifemin Menopause Relief Tablets, product listing. Walmart
This article reflects one person’s experience and is for general information only. It is not medical advice. Talk with your healthcare provider before starting any supplement.


Leave a Reply